You Thought You Had Me

Of all the stars that fell from the sky
You were the one that ended up my guy
My bets were set, my cards were played
You always thought I'd stay no matter what you said
It was true for a time, my hand you did hold
I was waiting to see your hand before I'd fold
And, oh, how you said you would always be mine
I sucker your false faces every time

And you, you thought you had me fooled
You broke every last rule
But baby, I was gambling too
Baby, I was gambling too

With all the spells whispering words to me
Of your past betrayals and indecency
And you come home with that crooked grin
Thinking you'd get away in the end
But come now, baby, I'm sure you'll soon see
I am not another heart that you can commandeer
My bets are set, My cards I did chose
All that time, I had been betting that you'd lose

And you, you thought you had me fooled
You broke every last rule
But baby, I was gambling too
Baby, I was gambling too
I was betting you would lose