Where in the World Is Greencastle Indiana?

Are you in space?
Are you on Jupiter?
Are you in New York?
Are you on Greencastle?

Yes I miss you so much
Where'd you go?

Are you a photographer?
Are you an art major?
Are you a sex symbol?
Are you a professor?

Yes I miss you so much
Where'd you go so?
So far away

Will you marry me?
Will you be my wife?
Here's your ring
I'll marry you
I wanna be your wife

Yes I miss you so much
Where'd you go?
So far away